Electric boilers are often praised for their simplicity, cleanliness, and near-100% efficiency. But despite these benefits, they remain a niche option in home heating. Why? In this post, we’ll explore the key reasons why electric boilers aren’t more widely adopted and when they do make sense.
🔌 1. High Running Costs
Although electric boilers convert nearly all the electricity they consume into heat, the price of electricity is significantly higher than that of gas in most areas. This translates into higher energy bills. For example, in Falkirk, Scotland, the installation of electric boilers in hundreds of council homes led to residents facing energy bills of up to £100 per week.
🏠 2. Not Ideal for Larger Homes
Electric boilers typically have a lower heat output compared to gas alternatives. This makes them less effective for larger properties or households with high hot water demands. If you have multiple bathrooms or need to run several taps at once, an electric boiler may struggle to keep up.
⚡ 3. Electrical Load and Infrastructure Challenges
Many older homes were not built to handle the high amperage that electric boilers require. Upgrading your electrical system to meet the boiler’s needs can be costly and inconvenient. Plus, during a power outage, an electric boiler will stop working completely—no heating, no hot water.
🌍 4. Environmental Impact Depends on Power Source
While electric boilers themselves produce zero emissions, their green credentials depend on how the electricity is generated. If your electricity comes from fossil fuels, the carbon footprint may be just as high as a gas boiler. Homes powered by renewable energy, like solar, have a clear advantage here.
🛠️ 5. Shorter Warranties and Upfront Costs
Electric boilers often come with shorter warranties—2 to 3 years on average—while gas boilers may offer up to 10 years. Installation costs can also be higher, especially if you need to upgrade your home’s electrical setup.
🔄 6. Heat Pumps: The Rising Alternative
Heat pumps are increasingly seen as a more energy-efficient alternative. Unlike electric boilers, heat pumps don’t generate heat—they move it, often achieving efficiencies of 300% or more. That means lower running costs and less environmental impact.
✅ When Do Electric Boilers Make Sense?
Despite their drawbacks, electric boilers can be the right choice in specific situations:
-
Small homes or apartments with modest heating needs
-
Off-grid properties without access to gas
-
Homes with solar panels or other renewable energy sources
In these cases, the compact size, ease of installation, and clean operation of electric boilers can be real advantages.
Final Thoughts
Electric boilers may not be the best fit for every home, but they offer a viable, low-maintenance alternative to gas or oil in the right setting. As electricity grids get greener and more homes add solar panels, we may see electric boilers become a more common sight.
